Favorite movie of all time?

What an impossible question! But we give it a go, don’t we, peeps? I’ve rated 245 films on IMDb, awarding seventeen of them 10/10. They include Some Like It Hot, Schindler’s List, Oppenheimer, Edge of Tomorrow, The Greatest Showman and Great Expectations.

I’ve rated 245 films on IMDb, awarding seventeen of them 10/10. They include Some Like It Hot, Schindler’s List, Oppenheimer, Edge of Tomorrow, The Greatest Showman and Great Expectations.

Surely I should be allowed a favourite comedy, thriller, romance, science-fiction film, musical and tearjerker?

But them’s not the rules! Answer the question, Vernon!

So, after considerable deliberation, I’m choosing All Quiet on the Western Front (1930), directed by Lewis Milestone and adapted from Erich Maria Remarque’s literary masterpiece.

Not the excellent 2022 adaptation. The original, made nearly a century ago, just twelve years after the First World War ended.

Why?

Because it’s magnificent cinema. Because it’s history. Because it’s a devastating anti-war film. And because its themes — jingoism, nationalism, sacrifice, camaraderie, fear, survival, love and the terrible waste of young lives — haven’t aged at all.

Look at Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

The film is also a fascinating introduction to the history of cinema. Black and white, no CGI, filmed during the transition from silent to sound, with extraordinary battle sequences and camerawork. It’s an American production, in English, based on a German novel about German soldiers.

But there’s a more personal reason for my choice.

In 1990, aged 29, I watched it on video with my grandfather. He was 95. The First Iraq War was making news in the papers and on TV.

All Quiet on the Western Front (1930) was his favourite film. It’s mine too! I hope I can persuade you to look it up.

My grandfather, Jack Wilson (born 1897), fought in the First World War, enlisting as an infantryman in January 1916 before being selected for the Machine Gun Corps. He served on the Western Front, including the Somme, Arras and Passchendaele, witnessing death, narrowly escaping it himself, and eventually ending the war as an RAF fighter pilot.

I’d listened eagerly to his stories since childhood. In the early 1990s, I had the opportunity to interview him extensively, write up his memoir and have him correct and annotate it, even adding hand-drawn maps.

Watching All Quiet on the Western Front with him gave the film an extraordinary immediacy. The young men on screen were experiencing much of what he had experienced.

Afterwards, he turned to me and said:

“That’s nothing compared to Passchendaele.”

I’ve never forgotten those words.

He was 95, recalling events from more than seventy years earlier, yet still conscious that another generation could be called upon to fight.

That’s why I believe the 1930 All Quiet on the Western Front is the film we should show schoolchildren when introducing the First World War.

Not Blackadder Goes Forth, brilliant though it is. Nor the 2022 adaptation, though comparing the two would make a fascinating lesson.

The original offers so much to discuss: literature, nationalism, propaganda, military recruitment, the expectations placed on young people, the realities of combat, the treatment of veterans and the history of filmmaking itself.

It belongs to an era when the war’s survivors were still everywhere, and its consequences were impossible to escape.

It is nearly a hundred years old, yet it has lost none of its urgency.

My grandfather watched it. I watched it with him. I hope another generation will watch it too.

If you haven’t seen it, please do.

All Quiet on the Western Front (1930) — IMDb

And remember what my grandfather told me:

“You should watch out; they could call you up.”

Leave a Reply

Trending