I Loved this offered by fellow OU Student.

Mind maps can be such twaddle.

For a few days I taught Tony Burzan in Secondary Schools; the best mind map wasn’t a mind map at all, it was a football field.

I was not invited to continue with my efforts to teach memory tricks and cheats after that my second only effort to occupy 40 Year 9s.

Another blog, another day …

An eventful seven hours or so. Despite the need for an essay plan, bullet points or an ordered list.

I tried to write a TMA from a mind map and got myself as ludicrously tied in knots as it is with unlinked threads and a failure to group the content; a Venn Diagram would have worked better. Which is a point as applicable to the software that creates these things, know your tools and choices and make them. Sometimes the old, simple ways work best. Essays and assignments, like a narrative, are linear.

My A’ level Geography teacher Mr D.Rhodes of the Newcastle R.G.S had the best approach.

An essay should look like a flower

  • six petals = six ideas
  • the stamen = the topic
  • the stem = the introduction and conclusion.

A shorthand doodle at the end of an essay would often feature such a flower with ONE huge leaf until I got the picture. It must have worked; how else did I get into Oxford?

An essay plan or treatment, unlike a mind-map, requires effort, concentration and thought.

2 responses to “Six ways to debunk the mindmap in favour of the essay plan”

  1. Jonathan, I do like this assessment of mind maps – they seem great as brain dumps, but you still have to structure what is in your mind. So a good tool for those who have so many words in their head that they don’t know where to start. And following that brain dump exercise up with the idea of the flower with six petals is perfect. I wish someone had told me that a few years ago when I had to write essays for my Masters degree. Professor Hammersley still remembers the trouble I had to write essays.

    1. Trouble is I just winged it with the mind map for a TMA; never again. Professionally as a writer I am always meticulous about structure from synopsis to treatment to first, second, third and final drafts; this is how I will write the ECA that is due at the end of September. Thanks for stopping by. Jonathan.

Leave a Reply

Trending

Discover more from J F Vernon Blog

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading